Home Society and Culture The Transgender Issue

The Transgender Issue
Read in 10 min.
Listen in 13 min.
Learn the key ideas of the book by Shon Faye

The Transgender Issue

Overcoming discrimination and prejudice against trans people

The Transgender Issue highlights the many forms of discrimination that trans people face every day. Written by Shon Faye, a transgender journalist, the book describes stories and events that support trans people and their demand for equal rights and dignity. The discrimination they face comes from many different areas of their lives, from work and sport, to medical care and the controversial issue of fertility. It is a challenge to even talk about the issue, because trans people are so often treated as a problem that has to be controlled or solved. Going forward, all it would take, especially in the UK, would be some level of political and social commitment, to be able to integrate trans people into society and finally allow them equal opportunities.

The Transgender Issue
Read in 10 min.
Listen in 13 min.

Trans people still experience enormous adversity, because they are so often seen, but not heard

The term ‘trans’ refers to every person who does not identify with the biological gender they were assigned at birth. Although there are many variations within this definition, the term mostly refers to people who were born male but identify as female (trans-women), and people who were born female but identify as male (trans-males).

People tend to shy away from the topic, so there is rarely an opportunity for constructive debate on the issue. When people talk about the ‘trans issue’, it is often implied that this is something we need to deal with, that is a problem that we need to solve. In this book, writer Shon Faye has collected the many stories she has heard over the years, in order to show just how difficult life can be for a trans person, and how much of a problem it also poses for non-trans people. Faye focuses on the reality of the situation in her home country of England.

During the 2019 UK election campaign, Jo Swinson, the leader of the Liberal Democratic Party, was criticised for opening up a debate on transgender rights. Her progressive ideas were suppressed, because most people prefer not to talk openly about these issues. During the 2020 elections, every political leader was specifically asked for their opinion on the transgender issue. It would appear, therefore, that the issue is of great interest, but only if approached in a very specific and limited way. Trans people are belittled, almost dehumanised, and reduced to an issue: their very status as human beings is often completely ignored.

As a journalist, Shon Faye has repeatedly been called upon to talk about trans people on the radio, television, and in the press, but has found that the media often treats the trans community in a condescending way, as if it were something to be ridiculed or forgiven. Trans people are seen as a problem or issue that society has to deal with, but the vast majority of people lack any kind of curiosity to learn about the lives of trans people, who in turn, are just asking to be heard.

It is also true that debates always start with non-trans people, rather than the other way around, because trans people are never given the chance to open up a dialogue. The more courageous in the trans community, who are active on social media and fight to claim their place in the world, are often silenced, because they are seen simply as angry activists who are unable to accept any kind of criticism. It is almost impossible to hold a simple debate, because the latent prejudice against trans people always wins out in the end, and their voices go unheard. Everyone sees them and judges them, but no one really listens to them as they deserve to be listened to.

Faye seeks justice for all the trans people who are marginalised and discriminated against by society, and for those who are denied their basic rights, such as health security or employment. Trans people are not, and cannot, be free, because their right to freedom is not fully recognised. According to Faye, however, the time has come to do something, so that trans people are no longer abused, mistreated, or subjected to violence.


The key ideas of "The Transgender Issue"

Trans people still experience enormous adversity, because they are so often seen, but not heard
Parental support is crucial in allowing a trans person to accept themselves
A transphobic society produces unhappy and conflicted people
One of the most difficult times for a trans person is transitioning from one gender to another
What might life look like for trans people in the UK in the near future?
Take-home message
4books preview

Try 4books Premium for free!